Doctor Who – Enlightenment (The Black Guardian Trilogy Part 3)

Doctor Who Story 127 – Enlightenment

Written by

Barbara Clegg

What’s It About?

The Doctor, Tegan, and Turlough are contacted by the White Guardian, but his message is unable to come through clearly. Soon after they materialize on an Earth sailing ship crewed by Eternals and kidnapped humans. Bored by their existence, the Eternals are having a race. The winner receives enlightenment.

Superior beings do not punish inferiors.

Ships in spaceThemes of mortality and death in The Black Guardian Trilogy continue with the introduction of the Eternals, a race of beings who are immortal. They have strong psychic powers. And they are bored. Immortality is dull and dreary. What does one do with an eternal existence? Well, the current answer is to race sailing ships across a galaxy. This leads to some striking images throughout the story, both on the screen and conceptually. This is just a fun story to look at.

But what strikes me the most about this story, what captures my attention, is Turlough. We have seen a definite character arc for him, which is striking because the past few character departures (Nyssa and Adric) seemed so meaningless since the characters were not interesting. They did not live up to the potential that was introduced when they joined the TARDIS crew. Turlough, however, has been nothing but conflict. He is self-serving. He is a coward. He is deceitful. The only particular criticism I have with his introduction in “Mawdryn Undead” is that I wanted a better indication why he was this way other than being trapped on Earth, which was not his native planet.

Turlough has been a servant of the Black Guardian, who offered Turlough passage off Earth if Turlough would kill the Doctor. While Turlough is no longer bound to Earth, he has yet to kill the Doctor (obviously) and has waffled endlessly about the situation. From a religious standpoint, Turlough made a deal with the devil, and now he can’t find a way out of the deal. But part of his dilemma lies not in his goodness, his desire to not kill the Doctor, but in his ability to commit to a side. Turlough wants to do his own thing, follow his own impulses and desires. But many of those desires up to this point have been self-destructive or harmful toward others. Turlough, then, becomes indecisive, not willing to do what needs to be done for the Black Guardian, but not willing to give up his own selfishness to fully reveal his predicament to the Doctor (who could save him, this story makes clear). “Enlightenment” pivots when Turlough is faced with death on Wrack’s ship. He cries out to the Black Guardian for help, but he is denied. Finally, for the first time Turlough calls out to the Doctor, who arrives just in time to save him. As such, “Enlightenment” can be read as a story about salvation and redemption. In the end, the decision is up to Turlough. He can use his reward from the race to kill the Doctor or break his contract. As the Doctor says, “Enlightenment [the prize for the race] was the choice.” The only way to throw off the contract was to choose something else, to embody a new story. To become the companion, not be the villain.

There are many ways someone could read “Enlightenment” in the context of The Black Guardian Trilogy. The themes in this story lend themselves to multiple interpretations, which is probably why this story is the most popular of the three. It resonates on many levels. It speaks to our humanity.

My Rating


4 thoughts on “Doctor Who – Enlightenment (The Black Guardian Trilogy Part 3)

  1. I have always liked this trilogy of stories. As you’ve commented before, besides the obvious continuing subplot of Turlough and the Black Guardian, it has the overall theme that immortality is not all its cracked up to be, that being human and having a finite lifespan is really a blessing. Given the opportunity to live for eternity, many beings discover that existence without end is actually a curse. Certainly the Doctor of all people can appreciate that sentiment, given all the loneliness he has endured over the centuries, the people who have come in and out of his life, while he has to keep going on and enduring. That has certainly become a MAJOR theme of the series since it was revived in 2005.

    By the way, there is they theory that the Doctor figured out pretty early on in this sequence of stories what was going on with Turlough, that he was involved with the Black Guardian. Back in Mawdryn Undead, the Doctor also comments to the Brigadier that the amazing level of coincidence surrounding events seems to indicate some sort of “cosmic influence” at work. And then the Doctor discovers the crystal that Turlough was given by the Black Guardian. The Doctor’s thoughtful look shows that he realizes the crystal is significant. When he later finds Turlough, the Doctor tosses the crystal to him, casually commenting “Yours, I think.” Someone once suggested that the crystal might be made of the same substance as the Key To Time, cluing in the Doctor that the Guardians are involved. And so he might very well have invited Turlough to join the TARDIS crew both to keep an eye on him and to test him, to see where his loyalties lay, and give him an opportunity to redeem himself.

    1. These are great stories and I think if anyone were to ask what stories they should check out that would epitomize the best of the Davison era, I would probably recommend this trilogy.

      While none of the stories confirmed it, I would agree that the Doctor figured out Turlough pretty early on. It didn’t seem clear from the scripts, but the way certain moments were shot implied this. I think the overall theme for Turlough was redemption, and I think the Doctor knew that this new companion could change. He saw the possibility.

      A great group of stories indeed.

  2. This trilogy sounds fascinating! The only Davison episode that I’ve seen is “The King’s Demons” which was…unremarkable. Do you think I would be able to jump in at the beginning of this trilogy or would I need to go back and watch some earlier episodes for set up?

    1. While it is nice to see stories in context, I think the Davison era largely failed to really set up character arcs with the exception of Turlough. So, no, you don’t need to watch anything which came earlier in the season. These three stories work quite well without any set up.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s