Written by Ian Goldberg and Andrew Chambliss
Directed by Victor Nelli
The amnesiac David Nolan must decide to return to the wife he doesn’t remember or Mary Margaret, whom he is deeply attracted to.
For the most part, this episode was a return to form. And while Emma Swan was rather irritating and the CG was terrible, the emotional struggle of David and Mary Margaret made the episode satisfying. First, I was nervous as to how this struggle would be dealt with. All too often, the Hollywood answer is to “follow your heart.” But how does one follow their heart when they exist in a dual state? Prince Charming was married to Snow White, but David is married to Kathryn. So far as we know, this new world, this mundane world, features fully-realized relationships. How does one reconcile faithfulness? Ultimately, David’s greatest crime is, as Mary Margaret said, leading her on. Ultimately, David chose his reality, and that reality was Kathryn.
Rather than recap the story (which is still available on ABC’s website), I wish to engage in some wild speculation. You see, I’m still holding this show at arm’s length. The writing (for the most part) is good, but American television tends to fail on the long-running arcs. I’ve mentioned before that I feel the best path for Once Upon a Time to take is to deal with arcs on a season by season basis, but I feel this is quite unlikely as we have been told that when the curse breaks the final battle will begin. This leaves only two large arcs: Break Curse, Fight Battle. Fair enough. However, I would like this show to do something unexpected and mind-bending. We have been told (in the opening sequence) that the fairy tale characters are now living in our world, but how much more interesting if they weren’t. What if it is the same world? What if the only thing that has changed are memories and perceptions of reality? So what would this mean? I believe that the rules would be the same. We have seen that agreements hold, regardless of where they were made. We have seen remnants of the old world (glass coffin, most of Mr. Gold’s shop). If this were a different world, why would the old world exist in it? I believe we are being told what Regina/The Queen believes to be true. Mr. Gold / Rumplestiltskin may have crafted something more deceptive: two worlds which are really one. Storybrooke IS the fairy tale world. The greatest hindrance to breaking the curse, then, would be if everyone decided to stay because they chose Storybrooke as reality. This may all be incorrect, but it would certainly be unexpected and so far, it fits certain clues we have been given.
What do you think? Is my theory crazy? Can you see evidence that I am wrong? Comment below.